Version 2 (modified by loeh@…, 13 years ago) (diff)

some additional shortcomings of the current "deriving" mechanism

Derived Instances

Automatic derivation of instances is jolly useful. Current problems are:

  • Automatic derivation is only available for certain classes defined in the Prelude and standard libraries.
  • There is no way to specify how to derive a user-defined class in the general case.
  • There is no way to derive an instance of a class for a data type that is defined elsewhere (in another module).
  • There is no easy way to refer to the definitions that would have been derived when defining an explicit instance.
  • Deriving fails for some Haskell-98 data types. Try
    data Rose f a = Fork a (f (Rose f a)) deriving Show
    as an example.
  • Even in the absence of user-defined deriving, it should be easy for a 'newtype' decl to inherit some of the instances of its parent type, no matter where the class was defined, but this is currently only available as a ghc extension to haskell'98.

There are various extant proposals to enable the user-specification of the derivation of class instances.

  • fill out a list