Version 28 (modified by john@…, 11 years ago) (diff)



on the wiki:


Papers and other docs:


what is required by the standard

At least the following interface will be provided

  • Control.Concurrent.MVar - everything except addMVarFinalizer
  • Control.Concurrent - ThreadId, myThreadId, forkIO, yield, sleep (replaces threadDelay).
  • Control.Concurrent.Chan, Control.Concurrent.QSem, Control.Concurrent.QSemN, Control.Concurrent.SampleVar

the FFI must be able to handle 'concurrent nonrentrant' imports, but not necessarily 'concurrent reentrant' ones.

Progress Guarentee

  • if any haskell thread is runnable then at least one thread will be running.
  • foreign calls marked 'concurrent' will not interfere will the above rule.

Additionally, we have a fairness property of MVars:

  • A thread blocked on an MVar will eventually run, provided there are no other threads holding the MVar indefinitely.

This means that MVar blocking must be implemented in a fair way, eg. a FIFO of blocked threads.

In order to meet the progress guarentee, an implementation must yield to another thread, waiting for an appropriate event, before any action that entails blocking for an indeterminate amount of time.

MVar Guarentees

initial proposal is here:

Alternate, simpler proposal: full memory barrier at every putMVar and takeMVar.

perhaps a better phrasing of the first proposal exists, in practice, from a users point of view, it would be hard to tell the difference between the two models, but we should say something concrete on the matter.

Misc library stuff

yield is guarenteed to choose an alternate thread if another one exists and is runnable.

sleep guarentees the thread will wait as long as its argument at a minimum. it may be blocked for longer.


I/O operations from System.IO, System.Directory, System.Process (and others?) do not prevent other threads from making progress when they are waiting for I/O to complete.

We could provide a lower-level non-blocking I/O interface along the lines of threadWaitRead, threadWaitWrite, perhaps in Control.Concurent.IO.

Optional extensions to basic standard

These are optional extensions a compiler may implement. In some implementations they may entail a run-time cost to non-concurrent code or a compiler might need a special option to enable them. However, A compiler is not required to provide more than one concurrency model as long as it can meet the requirements of the standard and any options it claims to support.

If a compiler documents that it supports one of the following options, then it must adhere to the rules of that option as well.

Optional Feature 1 - Preemption

The standard only requires a progress guarentee, that a thread is always running, making progress. If an implementation supports context switching during arbitrary computations and meets the stronger fairness guarentee below, then it can be said to support the 'Preemption' option.

Fairness Guarentee

  • no starvation

new library calls provided

  • mergeIO, nmergeIO

Optional Feature 2 - OS threads

The implementation additionally allows the following:

  • foreign exported functions, and function pointers created by foreign import "wrapper", can be invoked from multiple OS threads
  • bound threads: forkOS, isCurrentThreadBound, runInBoundThread, runInUnboundThread
  • concurrent/reentrant foreign calls are supported

Notes - Sharing

Although not mentioned in the standard, the use of Concurrency may affect the lazy sharing of computations. Consult an implementations documentation if this might be an issue for you.

Status of Compilers

standard concurrency: hugs, jhc(planned)

standard + preemptive: ghc, yhc

standard + preemptive + OS threads: "ghc -threaded"